I have always had ALLSTATE for my renters insurance, I tried another insurance company (for 2 weeks) but their premiums were all over the place, so I went back to ALLSTATE and have been with them for about 10 years. Mike is an awesome agent. The lady that takes my premium is very sweet. Thanks Debbie!😊 :-)
The Michael Neilitz agency is great. Mike cares about his customers and he or his staff has always been able to get the answer if a question arises. I've recommended several people to his agency over the years and some have signed up because Michael and/or his staff gets the job done.
Sadly, after years of being a customer our experience with having a car totaled in an accident has brought us to the point of not trusting Allstate to insure any of our possessions. The Neilitz group is very nice however they represent a company that in my opinion is not honest and forthright in its approach to insurance reimbursement. I am dissatisfied by the lack of effort put forth by my agent in the process of trying to get proper reimbursement for my totaled vehicle. I believed my agent to be my advocate and that is not the case. Some helpful advice was what was available, nothing more. Now I get to wrangle multiple insurance companies as well as my own to properly reimburse and value my vehicle correctly. Frustrating to say the least.
The Neilitz group always gave me great service but Allstate as a company I could never recommend. My truck was insured and after I took it off and later tried to put it back on I was told I couldn't unless I went to DMV to prove it was road worthy. I was stuck out of state with no way to get home. I called a few other agencies and none of them would have any problem insuring my truck. So I picked a new insurance company for all my policies.